The World Bank has said President Tinubu’s economic reform programme has pushed up Nigeria’s poverty level with over 104 million Nigerians now living below the poverty line.The key reforms include the removal of petrol subsidy and the foreign exchange market rate restructuring.
The bank in its latest report, however, commended the Federal Government for what it considered ‘bold reforms’ necessary to rescue Nigeria from fiscal cliff, describing the current pains as temporary.
But it also said the policies have created intense pressures on cost of living, which have pushed more Nigerians into hardship.
The World Bank report also indicated that the number of poor people in Nigeria had grown from 95 million in 2021 to 100 million in 2022, while the Nigerian Bureau of Statistics (NBS), indicated that the figure was 82.9 million in 2019 and 85.2 million in 2020.
In its World Bank Nigeria Development Update (NDP), entitled ‘Turning the Corner: Time to Move From Reforms to Results’, the bank stresses the need to continue with the reform momentum to complete the reforms and to address the costs of the reforms.
It further stated: ‘‘Inflation remains at record high levels for Nigeria, 27.3 per cent Year-on-Year (YoY), in October 2023, partly driven by the one-off price impacts of the removal of the gasoline subsidy.
‘‘The impact of this is especially hard on poor and vulnerable citizens. The FX market has remained volatile and in a period of continuing adjustment to the new policy approach, with significant fluctuations in the exchange rate in both the official and the parallel markets. Revenue gains from the FX reform are visible.
‘‘However, there is a need for more clarity on oil revenues, especially the financial gains of Nigeria National Petroleum Corporation Limited, (NNPCL), from the subsidy removal, the subsidy arrears that are still being deducted, and the impact of this on Federation revenues.”
In his appraisal of the country’s reforms, World Bank Country Director for Nigeria, Shubham Chaudhuri, stated: “The petrol subsidy and FX management reforms are critical steps in the right direction towards improving Nigeria’s economic outlook. Now is the time to truly turn the corner by ensuring coordinated fiscal and monetary policy actions in the short to medium term.
“Continued reform implementation can ensure that Nigeria benefits from the difficult adjustments underway. This includes ensuring that improved oil revenues following the sharply increased PMS price accrue to the Federation.
‘‘In the medium-term, the economy will then begin to benefit from increasing fiscal space for development spending, including on power and transport infrastructure, as well as on human capital.”
He further said that between N300 billion –N400 billion was expended on fuel subsidy monthly, before the subsidy removal and that the expectation was that the NNPCL should have been paying such amount to the Federation Account, but which has not been the case.
The latest NDU report recommended specific actions required to further sustain and achieve the full benefits of reforms already embarked on by the Government.
These include: controlling inflation and improving the stability of the FX market; achieving fiscal consolidation by sustaining savings from the PMS subsidy reform and improving non-oil revenues; addressing structural barriers to growth, such as removing trade barriers.
It stated further: “With the continued implementation of macroeconomic stabilization reforms, Nigeria’s economy is expected to grow at an average annual rate of 3.5 per cent in 2023-2026, or 0.5 percentage points higher than in a scenario where the reforms had not been implemented.
World Bank Lead Economist for Nigeria and co-author of the Report, Alex Sienaert, also stated: ‘‘In 2024, Nigeria has an opportunity to turn the corner to a more stable and predictable macroeconomic environment, and easier access to foreign exchange (FX) and imported inputs, which is critical to creating new jobs and lifting people out of poverty”.
The NDU report indicated that Nigeria was not yet out of the woods but on the path to full recovery, as a result of the various policies being implemented by both fiscal and monetary authorities.
The World Bank called on the Nigerian National Petroleum Company Limited (NNPCL) to make public its Statement of Accounts and transparently disclose its revenue inflows.
The report read in part, “The removal of the subsidy was announced on May 29 and pump prices were adjusted on June1.
“This results in expected fiscal savings of around N2 trillion in 2023 or 0.9 percent of GDP.
“Between 2023 and 2025, the expected gains are over N11 trillion, against a scenario in which the subsidy had continued’’.
The Minister of Finance and Coordinating Minister for the Economy, Mr. Wale Edun, also insisted that NNPCL’s account must be audited.
His words, “There will be earnest scrutiny and I am sure NNPC is getting ready for that. We want revenue to come into the government coffers from NNPC and all other revenue agencies.”
The last two Ministers of Finance, namely, Mrs. Kemi Adeosun and Mrs. Zainab Ahmed had publicly said that the accounts of the NNPCL would be looked into, but there has been no report of such audit made public.
Mr. Edun also revealed that the federal government would come up with a new structure of salaries in 2024.
He did not give details, other than that it was statutory to review salaries every five years, according to the Salaries and Wages Commission Act and that all stakeholders including labour leadership would be involved.
The Minister of Finance revealed that wealthy Nigerians were holding huge sums of dollars and other foreign currencies in their Domiciliary bank accounts in the country.
According to him, there was a lot of FX liquidity in Nigeria and the Federal Government would take steps to make holders of such accounts release the money.
Mr. Edun said that the government would not force holders of such accounts to give them up but would provide incentives to enable them invest in attractive instruments, going forward.
The Governor of the Central bank of Nigeria, Mr. Olayemi Cardoso, who was a panelist at the NDU presentation said that he was not against quasi fiscal interventions by the CBN but that his focus would remain how to reduce inflation through price stability.
On the controversy around his failure to convene a Monetary Policy Meeting since coming into office, the governor said that the past frequent MPCs did not achieve their objectives and that he would not continue along that line.
His words, “To what extent did the meetings achieve their objectives? The answer is no. That is why we have chosen to do it differently. Holding these meetings take a lot of time and energy.”
According to him, his team holds Liquidity Management meetings every 8.00 am to review the liquidity situation in the system and that he would take every necessary action to mop up excess liquidity in the system, adding, “we have increased OMO (Open Market Operations) both in value and volume.”
In her contribution, the Minister of Industry, Doris Uzoka-Anite, disagreed with the position of the World bank on Power subsidy.
The bank had advocated a power regime without subsidy in order to boost investor confidence and ensure a cost- reflective tariff.
However, the minister insisted, “there is nothing wrong with the power sector subsidy. Subsidy in the power sector is a subsidy that supports production. Countries everywhere support production and export.”